D.M.,
Texas
(return
to member listing)
You mentioned my spiritual odyssey, and it has indeed been curious.
Actually I have been friendly disposed towards Jodo Shinshu ever since
1960 (40 years ago!), when I read a book called, "Buddhism and Jodo
Shinshu." Prior to that, I had seen only anthologies by the likes of
Christmas Humphreys and Edward Conze or Zen books by Suzuki and others.
When I was in college in the late '40s, I took the correspondence course
from the British Buddhist Society, which leaned mostly towards Theravada.
All of these authors convinced me that Buddhism was wonderful, but I, the
happily married father of a young family, could not possibly be a Buddhist
myself. I had no desire whatsoever to become a monk.
"Buddhism and Jodo Shinshu," however, showed that there
exists a Buddhism which is for anyone, even for the likes of me. I read
the book over and over, underlining passages and wearing out the pages. I
immediately loved the "Tannisho," which was included in the book, and have
marveled at it ever since. I also subscribed to the magazine, "The
American Buddhist," and received it for many years. However, my way
through the door of Shinshu was stopped dead by a remark by Rennyo:
"There must not be even a dewdrop of doubt" (V.21). How is such
a thing possible? How can there not be a dewdrop of doubt? I have always
had rivers of doubt -- oceans. How could I just will them to dry up and
disappear?
After graduating from college in Mexico, I went to theological
seminary, first at Princeton and then at Philadelphia Lutheran, on your
old stomping ground of Germantown Avenue in Mount Airy. Existentialism was
in vogue in those days, and I, too, was taken up by it. Existentialism,
not the Bible, was the key to faith. The Bible was analyzed like any other
piece of ancient literature, and thus it became a problem, not a solution.
The Christian had to make an existential leap of faith. Once we had
arrived on the other side of the chasm, we were told, everything would
look different. But I teetered on the brink, unwilling to jump into space.
Finally I chose the Eastern Orthodox Church precisely to avoid the
existential leap. The Eastern Church was a historical entity, something
which could be seen and experienced. It was there as an actual fact and
had been there for centuries, perhaps even back to the time of Christ. If
Christ were true, his handiwork must be true, too. We could see and
experience this handiwork (so ran the argument) in this ancient Church,
which was His very Body. I was ordained a priest in 1953 and began parish
work the next year.
For the next five years I served in parishes of the Syrian Archdiocese,
which at that time was the only Orthodox jurisdiction encouraging the use
of English. However, instead of an existential leap I now had to make a
cultural leap, from Philadelphia to Lebanon. The one was as difficult as
the other.
By 1960, I had gone from from full-time pastor to part-time pastor and
full-time educator. (It was then I began reading on Jodo Shinshu.) In
1962, we moved to Wayne, Pennsylvania, where I joined the faculty of
Valley Forge Military Academy. There I remained for 15 years, eventually
retiring as a colonel and chairman of the Foreign Language Department.
One day an old friend of mine, who had become an Orthodox bishop, paid
me a visit and begged me to take an Albanian parish in Connecticut. I
asked him, "What are Albanians like?" "They are the nicest
people in the world," he replied, "and the best cooks." It
turned out he was right on both counts. I served the Connecticut parish
for thirteen fruitful years, retiring in 1987 as an Archpriest. It was
while I was teaching in Pennsylvania in the 1960s that I first came upon
the Nichiren Buddhists, or rather, they came upon me. Some Sokagakkai
missionaries approached me on the streets of Philadelphia, and soon I was
attending meetings and trying to figure out what they meant by "Gohonzon"
and "benefits." Neither seemed very Buddhistic to me, but I was
able to gather a lot of material for my future book, "Fire in the
Lotus."
By the early 1970s, Reiyukai had entered the mission field, too. They
advertised a guided tour to "find Buddha in beautiful Japan" at
a very reasonable price, so one of my daughters and I took them up on
their offer. We had a grand time although we learned more about fellowship
and veneration of ancestors than we did about Buddhism. President Kubo,
though, struck me as a good man and a serious scholar. Reiyukai recruited
me to speak at their centers in Japan and write articles and even a book
in English on Buddhism.
During one of my trips to Japan, I met Murano Sensei, who was then
teaching at Rissho University. He took me to the Head Temple of Nichiren
Shu to meet the Lord Abbot. Later on Nichiren Shu had me do some English
books for them. Murano and I liked each other from he start, and as the
years passed we became good friends. He stayed at our place in Connecticut
and I at his in Hawaii on a number of occasions. I helped him with his
revision of the Lotus Sutra in English, and he helped me gather material
for my book on Nichiren Buddhism. One of his sons visited us in Texas, and
our son went to see him in Japan. After my retirement from the ministry, I
began to write a lot of material on Nichiren Buddhism and considered
myself a disciple of Murano Sensei even though I still could not accept
all the tenets of Nichirenism.
We exchanged so many letters than he even published some of them in a
small book, which he published in 1998. While I was in the Church, I
always firmly believed that I must be loyal to the ecclesiastical
authorities who had appointed me and the people who depended on me. I was
careful not to mix my Buddhist avocation with my Christian vocation
(although
once a newspaper writer after interviewing me did just that, labeling me a
"Buddhist Christian"). Likewise, in my Buddhist studies I felt I
must remain loyal to my good teacher, Murano, and wait until he died
before striking out on my own. But he seems to have no intention of dying,
bless his heart!
Meanwhile I continued studying Shinshu. I read your Shinran's
"Gospel of
Pure Grace" twenty years ago and took your correspondence course ten years
ago, learning much from both. I also read everything available in English
by Shinran and even struggled with some of his Japanese writings. Frankly,
I have always found Shinran far more convincing than Nichiren. The latter
is pedantic and academic, while the former is philosophical and personal.
However, that dewdrop of doubt would not vanish away.
What finally began to crack things open was my trip to Korea in May.
There I found Pure Land expounded as an integral part of Mahayana as a
whole, capable of illuminating Zen, esotericism, or Tendai. At the same
time, the deficiencies of Chinese Pure Land practice became glaringly
apparent, too, and it was Shinran who had revealed and resolved these
deficiencies. Chinese Pure Land stresses continuous and mindful chanting
of the Name. Everything comes to a head at the moment of death.
The whole
fate of the devotee hinges on that last second of life. If he gets
distracted for one instant, all his years of practice will have been in
vain. If he can keep his mind fixed on Amida, he is destined for the Pure
Land. But if his attention wanders to anything else -- his wife or his
children, for instance -- he is doomed. One of the books I brought back from
Korea contains a whole chapter devoted to the special care friends and
family must give to the patient during his last moments to make certain
that nothing distracts him from steady concentration on Amida Buddha.
Instead of assurance, the practitioner faces the most dreadful test of his
life.
Here the Shinshu Creed speaks with special force: "We believe that
the assurance of our rebirth through his Salvation comes at the very
moment we put our Faith in him," that is, when we see with clarity,
not when we struggle with the pangs of death. As for my dewdrops of doubt,
they are part of my makeup. I cannot change them. Amida accepts me as I
am, dewdrops and all.
I was reared Southern Baptist, learning to fear a punishing God. My
early years were spent cultivating guilt, shame, and the knowledge that I
would never be a good person, but always a sinner. As so many, during my
teens I rebelled, refusing to step foot in the church. I spent the
following decades searching, but I couldn't tell you what I was searching
for. Finding myself abandoned at age 38, with an 8-month-old baby and no
job, I returned to the religion of my youth. There was comfort in
familiarity. But that year reaffirmed the reasoning I left twenty years
earlier. I left, more mentally defeated than before.
Having been unable to find employment, and knowing my son had only me
to take care of him, I counted my losses, moved from San Diego to
Bakersfield in order to return to college. Living in Bakersfield is much
easier (read "cheaper") to live in when going to college,
working part time, and raising a child on your own. I am in my senior
year, majoring in history.
During this time, I ventured into a new age group. Their main concern
was meditating, through self-hypnotism, in order to acquire material
things. This supposedly was all that was needed to make a person happy.
This materialistic view always bothered me. I have, over the years,
learned to live simply, and this type of lifestyle was just not for me.
But I felt that perhaps the teachings of this group, along with
hypnotherapy and life regression, could help me control this great anger
that permeated in and around me. It didn't. But through this experience I
did gain a steadfast belief in reincarnation, and knowing there was a
place that all people go, after death, a way station of sorts, to re-group
before being re-born.
Therefore, when I had to take a required course on religion, I chose
Religions of India. This class, surprisingly, was almost too easy for me.
It seemed everything being taught was already a part of me. But when we
came to Buddhism in the latter part of the course, I was blown away!
"Living Buddha, Living Christ," by Thich Nhat Hanh was the required text
for this particular portion of the course. Here were answers to questions
I've had for so very long. Needless to say, the following lectures on
Buddhism, and the explanation of what the "Pure Land" was had me
enraptured. But it wasn't until the professor, after hearing my
explanation to his question on what we perceived as "One-Self"
looked directly at me in class and said, "Nancy, you're a Buddhist,
but you just don't know it yet." I left class that day in a sort of
haze. I thought about his statement, and my enthusiasm for the material,
and the whole of everything that led me to this point in my life. My
professor is right, I am a Buddhist but now I know it.
It was only this past March 2000 that all of this happened. Not a very
long time ago, but I feel I've come home. My anger has slowly dissipated
with the knowledge gained with Buddhism. Then began my search for the
basics. The Internet is a great source of information. But at times the
amount of information becomes overwhelming. I found some fantastic web
sites; many that help converts to Jodo Shinshu who find accessibility to a
temple either hard or non-existent.
I flirted with Zen, of course, hasn't everyone? But found too much
emphasis on finding a teacher and a Sangha both are unavailable in my area
of the world, frustrating. Continuing my search, I found, on the Internet,
a meditation group located in Long Beach, and was accepted, via telephone,
to consider them my Sangha. They specialized in Theravadan Buddhism, which
I found to be intellectually stimulating, but also very solitary. It was
suggested I buy A Gradual Awakening written by Stephen Levine, in order to
help me learn to meditate. All of the self-hypnotism really messed me up
when it comes to meditating. The book made me realize not only how weak my
mind is (millions of jumping monkeys!), but also how little time I
actually had to meditate.
Being a full time Mom to a very healthy three-year-old, a full time
student, and working part time made the jumping monkeys in my mind the
least of my distractions! Also, I found the monasticism involved was
definitely not my cup of tea. I am a people person, and I love to talk and
touch! (And write J!) So, I turned to Thich Nhat Hahn and began reading
"The Teachings of Buddha." I felt I needed to know the succinct background
of Buddhism before all else.
It was during this time I discovered the Shin Forum and joined. I
didn't know what Shin was, but did know this forum dealt with Buddhism,
and perhaps I could pick up some pointers. At first all I received from
the letters being sent to the forum was mass confusion. Just what were
these people talking about? So, being the good historic researcher I am I
begin looking up anything and everything on the net that had a Shin, Jodo
Shin,
or Jodo Shinshu in it. And I read and read. The more I found, the more
interested I became.
Now my greatest challenge came to the forefront. I live in a city of
two hundred thirty seven thousand, two hundred twenty-two people. There
are seven full pages in the yellow pages listing various churches,
including one Islamic Mosque and one Sikh Temple. There are no Buddhist
Temples listed. One was built in June of this past year, a Thai Temple.
Since the opening, they have kept very low key. Simply stated, Buddhism,
and specifically Jodo Shinshu is relatively unheard of here.
I did find a Betsuin in a town 200 miles north of here, in Fresno, and
visited it some month's back. I enjoyed being there very much but find the
drive, 200 miles up and back in one day, rather daunting.
So, I keep myself busy reading books sent to me from my friends, and
reading the Forum. But still, I feel so isolated. This too, will pass. I
have been "doing" things to help propagate Jodo Shinshu in my
area. My hope is that some day I will be able to start a Ko here in this
town.
One of the first things I did, is order a "Buddha fish" from
http://www.bigmook.com
This fish goes on your car, like the Christian fish, but it is rather
fat, with the word "Buddha" in it. Yes, it gets noticed. And
yes, many comment on it. I've not had any bad remarks, just questions.
I've also had many interesting conversations with my friends. When I
get stumped, which is often, I turn to my mentors I've been fortunate to
meet on internet, for answers. This allows me to feel not so isolated.
Some other sites I've found, that may be of help follows:
http://www.vbtemple.org -- this is a great site for isolated beginners,
they have a complete daily tradition in Sanbutsuge, Juseige and Junirai,
available in Japanese, English and in audio.
http://www.fogbank.com - contains various essays, including some of my
favorites, "Parents Sharing the Nembutsu Teachings with their Young
Children" by Rev. K. Tanaka, and "Intro to Jodo Shinshu" by
Rev. K. Tsuji.
Another great site is http://www.mew.com
Also, there is a newsletter sent via e-mail, called "Dharmanotes".
This can be ordered free of cost by accessing http://dharmanotes.com
Through "snail-mail", one can request a catalog from the
Buddhist Bookstore located in San Francisco. This is the only catalog I
have found that has an extensive collection of Jodo Shinshu books. The
address for them is:
Buddhist Bookstore
1710 Octavia Street
San Francisco, CA 94109 (415) 776-7877
And by writing to the Society for Buddhist Understanding, one can
receive "The Teaching of Buddha" for an $8.00 donation, or free
if you can't afford it. I recommend this book to any Buddhist, it is one
to be kept bedside to read again and again. The address for this is:
Society for Buddhist Understanding
16925 E. Gale Avenue
City of Industry, CA 91745
(626)369-5035
Also, I have a friend who is working on "Dharma Talks" on
tape. I find this a fascinating and long awaited program for those of us
who are isolated or unable to attend Jodo Shinshu temples. As this program
progresses, I will let everyone know.
Also, I believe that we can all help one another, via e-mail,
telephone, and in person, just by being available, and being open-minded.
We are all from different backgrounds but have one goal, to be reborn in
the Pure Land.
The Name-that-calls has been seeking me
for lifetimes, it seems; whispers of its voice finding me in the depths
and crevasses of my involuted and wilful human career. At several crucial
junctures I have stopped to listen, and each time I breathlessly echoed my
thank you, but my monkey mind would grow impatient and bored and I would
be off to my next shiny moment.
I began life as a New York Jew and find myself 50 years later as a
Kentucky Buddhist. In between were many jobs, lovers, identities -- in
short, many lives. Looking back at it all I have to wonder how I got to
what I where I am -- whose wisdom and compassion have been behind,
beneath, and always in front of me?
In the 1928 Prayer Book of the Episcopal Church is the sentence "I
am a worm and no man." It was regarded as excessively groveling and
was removed in the 1978 revision. I, however, find it to the point and
strangely buoying. I have certainly not risen to the fullness of my being
-- bodhi -- and am crippled by choices and influences of my past.
Nevertheless, I am at the point in my life where I find I cannot dodge the
Name; it's call clings to me like fabric. And the good news it brings is
that I am beloved of the universe just as I am -- blind, foolish, and
pitiable.
Namu Amida Butsu.
I am an accountant who was born inHong Kong. My family has no formal
religious affiliation but my parents respected all major religions. I had
no interest in religion during my youth until one day in the early '80s I
encountered a book about Buddhism in a book store The book said that the
Buddha was not a god. I was surprised that Buddhism did not worship god
and was also shocked by my own ignorance about Buddhism.
Since then I bought many books about Buddhism and subsequently joined
an organization called The Dharmasthiti Buddhist Institute where I took
many courses on Buddhism including courses like Chinese Buddhism, Indian
Buddhism, Buddhist Logic, and courses on different schools like Tendai,
Hua-yen, Mind Only, Zen, etc. There were times when I went to the
institute several evenings a week in addition to joining the Sunday Sutra
gatherings despite the fact that I had a full time job. At that time I did
not pay too much attention on Pure land as I did not quite agree to its
teachings.
When I migrated to Canada in 1988, I encountered many obstacles in
adjusting to the new environment and fitting into the new society. I
took refuge in the three jewels after a dharma talk in a hotel with Master
Sheng-Yen of Dharma Drum Mountain. I joined the Dharma Drum Mountain's
community in Vancouver in practicing meditation for a while but stopped
mainly because of language barriers. Most people there spoke which I did
not understand nor speak too well. I then joined the Tung Lin Kok Yuen
Canada Societv, a Buddhist society originated from Hong Kong. I am still
taking their various courses on Buddhism but I seldom take part in the
religious rituals or ceremonies except in big days like the Chinese New
Year or the birthday of the Buddha.
In the process of adjusting myself to the new country, I discovered
that my self power was unable to solve all the problems. This was the time
when I started to look into Pure Land Buddhism. I got books on Pure Land
Buddhism but encountered a great difficulty.
Most of the books said that we should trust the primal vow and the Pure
Land Sutras because they were told by the Buddha. However, this was
against today's common perception that Mahayana Sutras were developed
several hundred years after the nirvana of the Buddha. I asked how could
anyone base his faith on something which was untrue. Instead of calming
myself I found myself more confused.
After thinking about the problem for a while, I knew that I loved many
Mahayana sutras The important thing was the message they sent and the
things they taught instead of their authority. I had to shift from
historical facts to the dharma itself. I listened to a dharma talk about
the Pure Land by a teacher who liked to use logic to present the
teachings. He concluded that the Pure Land was logical but I was still not
convinced.
As I had exhausted all means to understand the Pure Land, I put the
problem aside for a while until one day I visited the book store belonging
to the Buddha Light Mountain. I encountered a Chinese translation of a
book about the nembutsu by a Japanese writer. In that book, several
references were made to the "Tannisho." When I read the words of
the "Tannisho," I was deeply moved. I realized that the true
Pure Land way was in the "Tannisho."
I bought some books on Shin Buddhism from that book store. However,
books on Shin Buddhism in Chinese are rare. At the same time, one cannot
buy books on Shin Buddhism in English in regular book stores easily
neither. Fortunately, I was able to buy the book "Ocean: An
Introduction to Jodo-Shinshu Buddhism in America" by Kenneth Tanaka.
From that book I knew of the address of the Buddhist Book Store where I
obtained several books on Shin Buddhism.
Due to bad karma, I do not have the privilege to read your "Shinran's
Gospel of Pure Grace" but I did read your "The Life of Shinran
Shonin: The Journey of Self Acceptance," "Strategies for
Modern Living: A Commentary with Text of the Tannisho," and "Shoshinge:
The Heart of Shin Buddhism." Other books I like very much include Dr.
Taitetsu Unno's "River of Fire, River of Water," and more
recently his "Shin Buddhism: Bits of Rubble Turn into Gold."
Recently, I am able to get access to the internet where I found a lot
of information on Shin Buddhism and I discovered the Shin Dharma Net Cyber
Sangha. That is why I want to join.
Namu Amida Butsu